Risks of flushable wipes: Costco faces lawsuit over plumbing issues
A recent settlement revealed the potential dangers of flushing wipes marketed as “flushable”, highlighting a disconnect between consumer experiences and manufacturer claims
A recent class-action lawsuit settlement has drawn attention to the potential plumbing issues caused by “flushable” wipes, specifically those sold under the Costco brand, Kirkland Signature Premoistened Flushable Wipes. The lawsuit accused Costco of false advertising, as customers reported experiencing clogs and damage to their plumbing after using these wipes, which were marketed as flushable.
The lawsuit covers consumers who purchased the wipes in New York between July 2011 and May 2017, and eligible class members will receive US$1.30 per package as part of the settlement. Despite this, Costco continues to sell the wipes and has denied any wrongdoing, stating that the advertising claims are accurate.
This case is not isolated; Procter & Gamble faced similar accusations in 2015 regarding its Charmin Freshmates Flushable Wipes. Customers also reported plumbing problems linked to these wipes. In both instances, while settlements were reached, the companies continued to market their products as flushable.
Plumbing professionals emphasized that even wipes labeled as flushable can contribute to blockages. They note that these wipes take significantly longer to disintegrate than toilet paper, which can lead to complications when combined with other waste. Many municipalities have warned against flushing wipes altogether, regardless of their labeling, due to the substantial costs associated with plumbing repairs and sewer system maintenance.
Research indicates that there is little distinction between flushable and non-flushable wipes, as both do not break down completely in water. To mitigate the risk of clogs, plumbing experts recommend that consumers refrain from flushing anything other than toilet paper.
Consumers looking to evaluate the disintegration of flushable wipes versus regular toilet paper can conduct a simple test by placing both in water and shaking vigorously. If the wipe does not dissolve as quickly as toilet paper, it is deemed unsafe for flushing.
